Diagrams

The ideas on this site in eight diagrams. If you only have five minutes, scroll through these. Each links to the piece it comes from. Open any diagram full size, and download it as SVG or PNG to use with a credit to David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io.

The invisible damage

From When the work gets cheap

The saving from automating junior work shows up this year. The cost shows up years later, as a missing layer of experienced people, somewhere else in the business. No single report shows both, which is why it's easy to miss. It is avoidable: decide which work people keep because it teaches, and the line doesn't have to bend.

The invisible damageAutomating the junior work pays at once. What it costs shows up years later.Year 0Year 2Year 4Year 6Year 8Years after the junior work is automatedReported marginExperienced peopleThe damage is invisible hereThe saving shows upin this year's accountsThe cost arrives years later,in a different budgetDavid Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
Year 0Year 4Year 8Years after the junior work is automatedReported marginExperiencedpeopleThe damage isinvisible hereThe saving shows up in this year's accounts.The cost arrives years later,in a different budget.
Diagram 01

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Keep the work that teaches

From The bottom was the training programme

Most automation decisions sort tasks by what the output is worth. Sort them by what doing the task taught as well, and every junior task lands in one of four places. Automate what taught nothing. Where the task was how people learned, let the software draft and keep a person deciding, or keep a share of the volume for people. The right-hand column is where automating cuts into how people learn.

Keep the work that teachesSort junior tasks by what they taught, as well as what they were worth, before you automate any of them.Automate itWorth a lot, taught little.Bank the gain this quarter.A person decidesWorth a lot, and it taught.The software drafts; thedisagreements are the lesson.Delete itWorth little, taught little.No AI needed.Keep a shareWorth little, but it taught.Automate most; keep a setshare for people.What doing the task taught the person →What the output is worth →Where thelearning shockhappensDavid Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
Automate itWorth a lot,taught little.Bank the gainthis quarter.A persondecidesWorth a lot, andit taught. Thesoftware drafts;disagreementsare the lesson.Delete itWorth little,taught little.No AI needed.Keep a shareWorth little, butit taught. Keep aset share of itfor people.What doing the task taught →What the output is worth →The right-hand column is wherethe learning shock happens.
Diagram 02

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Better agents make worse supervisors

From The bottom was the training programme

Once a person is past about seventy per cent busy, the exceptions waiting for them pile up faster than they can clear them, and most plans staff supervisors towards a hundred per cent busy. The more reliable the automation, the worse people get at stepping in when it fails. Most plans assume one person can run far more agents than they can.

Better agents make worse supervisorsThe plan says one person runs forty agents. The evidence says the ceiling is much lower.0%25%50%70%100%How busy the supervisor isHow long an exception waitsPast about 70% busy,exceptions queue fasterthan one person clears themWhere mostplans staffsupervisorsAnd the more reliable the automation,the rustier the person who has to step in.David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
0%50%70%100%How busy the supervisor isHow long an exception waitsPast about 70% busy, exceptions queuefaster than one person clears them.Most plans staff supervisors near 100%.And the more reliable the automation,the rustier the person who steps in.
Diagram 03

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Earned, not assumed

From Earned autonomy

Along the bottom, how much your agents do without asking. Up the side, how much evidence you hold that they should. Most businesses are piloting, which is a fine place to start. The risk sits with businesses that have granted autonomy without the evidence behind it. To reach "earned", move up before you move across: get the evidence, then grant the autonomy.

Earned, not assumedGet the evidence before you grant the autonomy. The way to earned goes up before it goes across.EarningEvidence firstEarnedGrades published; demotions happenPilotingMost firms todayAssumingAutonomy without evidenceWatchesDraftsPreparesActsHow much your agents do without asking →A test set in usePublished criteriaA registerA listA slide deckEvidence you hold →David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
EarningEvidence firstEarnedGrades publishedPilotingMost firmsAssumingNo evidenceWatchesDraftsPreparesActsWhat agents do without asking →A test setCriteriaA registerA listA slide deckEvidence you hold →Get the evidence first. The way to earnedgoes up before it goes across.
Diagram 04

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

The layer you own

From The layer you own

Rent, license, host or run the models, step by step, and swap them when something better passes your tests. Own the layer underneath: one connected picture of your customers, your work and your decisions, a register of every agent with a named person against it, and a test set made from your own cases. The decision a customer relies on stays with a person.

The layer you ownHow I would put AI into a business: source the models step by step, route the work, own the layer underneath.SourceRent, license, host or runSwap any model when something better or cheaper passes your testsRoutePer step, not per workflowHard judgement to the best model · volume to the cheapest that passes · data rules firstRunAgents, built once as templatesIntakeResearchDraftingQuality checkReportingThe register: each agent's role, permissions, grade and a named personNot on the register? It doesn't run.OwnThe layer no vendor can sell youCustomersWorkPeopleRulesDocumentsDecisionsThe knowledge graph: one connected picture every agent reads and writesYour test set: your cases, right answers markedgrades every agent before it moves upread and writeSystems of record stay where they are, connected rather than replacedAlways a person:taking on a customer,signing off a decisionDavid Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
SourceRent, license, host or runSwap any model when a better one passes.RoutePer step, not per workflowHard judgement to the best model; volume to the cheapest.RunAgents, built once as templatesIntakeResearchDraftingQuality checkReportingThe register: role, permissions,grade and a named personAlways a person: taking on a customer,signing off a decision.OwnThe layer no vendor can sell youCustomersWorkPeopleRulesDocumentsDecisionsThe knowledge graph: one connected pictureevery agent reads and writes.Your test set: your cases, answers markedSystems of record stay where they are,connected rather than replaced.
Diagram 05

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Where the time actually goes

From Where the time actually goes

Take a customer's contract renewal that runs seventy days from start to finish, with only about four of them spent on the work. The rest is waiting on figures before and going round again after. Automating the work saves days; removing the waiting saves most of the seventy.

Where the time actually goesA customer's contract renewal: the work is small; the waiting around it is the prize.About four days of workDay 0Day 70Seventy days from start to finishFive minutes before:waiting on usage figuresfrom another teamFive minutes after:procurement sends it back withchanges to the same three clausesAutomate the work and you save days. Remove the waiting and you save months.David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
Five minutes before:waiting on usage figuresfrom another teamAbout four days of workDay 0Day 70Seventy daysFive minutes after:procurement sends it back withchanges to the same three clausesAutomate the work and you save days.Remove the waiting and you save months.
Diagram 06

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Go or stop, one stage at a time

From Where the time actually goes

One workflow at a time, through five stages, with a decision to carry on or stop between each, taken on measured evidence against criteria written down first. AI makes every stage faster. It doesn't remove a gate.

Go or stop, one stage at a timeOne workflow at a time, with a decision to continue or stop at every stage.IdeationShape it untilsomeone wouldpay for it1Goor stopDesignTest it with thepeople who willuse it2Goor stopExecutionBuild it andmeasure againstthe baseline3Goor stopAccelerationFaster, withoutlosing quality4Goor stopScalingNew markets,configured ratherthan rebuilt5Written down before the work starts: what would make us stopAt every gate: measured evidence against a baseline, decided in the room.AI makes every stage faster. It does not remove a gate.David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
Written down before the work starts:what would make us stop1IdeationShape it until someone would pay for itGo or stop2DesignTest it with the people who will use itGo or stop3ExecutionBuild it and measure against the baselineGo or stop4AccelerationFaster, without losing qualityGo or stop5ScalingNew markets, configured not rebuiltAt every gate: measured evidence against abaseline, decided in the room.AI makes every stage faster.It doesn't remove a gate.
Diagram 07

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Where the model runs

From The layer you own

There are four ways to get a model: rent it from the lab, license it through your cloud provider, host an open-weight model on machines you control, or run one on hardware you own. Choose step by step: the best rented model for rare, hard judgement, a small hosted model for high-volume work that can be checked, and your own hardware where nothing may leave. Whichever you choose, every model plugs into the same layer underneath, which is what makes changing one cheap.

Where the model runsRent, license, host or run, chosen step by step. Every model plugs into the same layer underneath.RentA lab's own serviceBest models firstLicenseThrough your cloudIn your regionHostAn open-weight modelOn machines you runRunYour own hardwareNothing leavesNewest models, nothing to runMost control, most to runOne workflowEach step chooses whereits model runsSorting what comes inthousands a day, easy to checkPulling the customer's history togethercustomer data stays in regionDrafting the recommendationneeds the best judgement availableRemoving personal datamust never leave the buildingChecking against your standardhas to behave the same next yearThe decision a customer relies on stayswith a named person, whichever model prepared it.The layer you ownEvery model plugs in hereA connected picture of the businessThe registerYour test setThe Friday test: could we change the model behind any step by Friday, and know by Friday whether the new one is as good?David Reynolds · ai.valuecreator.io
RentA lab's own serviceBest models firstLicenseThrough your cloudIn your regionHostAn open-weight modelOn machines you runRunYour own hardwareNothing leavesNewest modelsMost controlOne workflow, step by stepSorting what comes inthousands a day, easy to checkHostPulling the customer's history togethercustomer data stays in regionLicenseDrafting the recommendationneeds the best judgement availableRentRemoving personal datamust never leave the buildingRunChecking against your standardhas to behave the same next yearHostThe decision a customer relies onstays with a named person.The layer you ownEvery model plugs in here.A connected picture of the businessThe registerYour test setThe Friday test: could we change the modelbehind any step by Friday, and know it's as good?
Diagram 08

Download SVGDownload PNGLink to this diagram

Diagrams · On AI · David Reynolds